A Thanksgiving Contemplation

The recent unexpected political drubbing dealt America  followed by the eruption of vicious threats and promises from the hate-filled adherents of  chaos based on their darkest beliefs and who are soon to be seated in the Halls of Power and Justice has a fitting explanation.

Written in 1984 by William P. Hoar as a preface to Architects of Conspiracy: An Intriguing History, a compilation of articles that first appeared in American Opinion magazine. I set it aside as a source for the next chapter of the’Deep State’ series but after the results of election were announced and the democrats behavior went off the rails, I realized the books preface was a timely exposition of how  patient Satan is; then it occurred to me that it might help those who may  be wondering how did we get to this point.

Without further comment:

William P. Hoar’s Preface to Architects of Conspiracy

History doesn’t just happen.Men have deliberate goals for which they strive individually and collectively, the results which — regardless of the success of their missions — become history. Private ambitions and public posturing are seldom the same, so it is healthy to be wary of the ostentatiously altruistic. It was not without reason that Henry David Thoreau prepared to flee whenever he heard that someone was on the way to do him good.

That man is flawed, fallible, and roguish is no surprise to any outside the nursery, and it should not be shocking that the collective record seems worse than the sums of the parts. The historian Edward Gibbon had a professional understanding of the game, complaining that history is often “little more than the register of the crimes, follies and misfortunes of mankind”.

Such a registration by name, date, and place has frequently been all that the “accidentalists” want to discuss, ignoring the questions of why the world is run the way that it is, how, and by whom. Culpability is assigned by the winners, for the men who run things know what they are doing and do it anyway. Feathering one’s own nest is applied in the making of history, economics, politics, sociology, psychology, and morality. It is also applied in the writing of them. As Adam Smith observed two centuries ago in The Wealth of Nations: “It is not from the benevolence of the butcher, the brewer, or the baker that we expect our dinner, but from their regard to their self-interest.” So it is with history and historians.

The currents beneath the surface are usually the strongest and determine direction, while the casual observer sees but the reflections on top. With this in mind, we set out in the writing of these chapters to see and make clear to our readers what had been made murky by years of fashionable obfuscation.

Have men conspired throughout the ages? Have they cheated and pillaged, inflated and warred, and then labored to have the best light shone upon their motives? Such questions answer themselves, but apparently must be repeatedly asked. For, as Edmund Burke expressed it: “People will not look forward to posterity who never look backward to their ancestors.” Or inward to themselves.

Some will say that the evidence here or there in this survey is circumstantial, or that some case is not sufficiently made because the perpetrators didn’t plead guilty. To suggest that conspiracy might have been involved would be too, well, too revisionist. But the long arm of coincidence can only stretch so far. Propaganda is expected to fool most of the people some of the time, so one can only ask the honest reader to be at least equally skeptical of Establishment interpretation. Circumstantial? Take all the proof presented here, collate it with experience, and remember with Thoreau that “some circumstantial evidence is very strong, as when you find a trout in the milk.”

Of course, this book does have a point of view; there is a leitmotif. Human nature being what it is, few will enjoy being reminded of the vast evil at large in the world. During the French Revolution, for instance, the conspirator Mirabeau seriously declared that liberty “should have for her bed mattresses of corpses.” Accordingly, at one time, the French revolutionists had plans to kill half the population — just as was done by their Twentieth Century successors in Cambodia! The framers of the American Constitution, on the other hand, saw the terrible potential for collective evil and labored to avoid what George Washington called the “leveling principles.” The runaway “turbulence and follies democracy, “ in Edmund Randolphs’s phrase, must be resisted.

That is whyRandolph urged the Constitutional Convention to “check … and to restrain, if possible, the fury of Democracy.” Governeur Morris, our Minister to France during its bloody gyrations in the name of equality, actually called the unrestrained masses of people a “reptile.” Jefferson realized: “In questions of power… let no more be heard of confidence in man, but bind him down from mischief by the chains of the Constitution.” As the historians, Charles and Mary Beard put it in 1939, “when the Constitution was framed no respectable person called himself a democrat.” Which is why the created the Republic for which we stand.

It is that Republic which conspirators have been labor to wreck and submerge into a New World Order, or an all powerful United Nations, or some way station of regional government. It would be, we are told when we dare to demand an answer , for our benefit. Despots just love to do good, the means to that end notwithstanding. Take John Dewey, the demigod of the “Liberal” Education Establishment. In 1916, in Ethics, Dewey maintained that whether the use of force “is justifiable or not… is, in substance, a question of efficiency (including economy) of means in the accomplishing of ends… The criterion of value lies in the relative efficiency and economy of the expenditure of force as a means to an end.” Bowing to efficiency is still obsequy.

Consider the founder of the American Civil Liberties Union, Roger Baldwin, who in 1935 admitted: “ Communism is the goal.” By age 96, in 1981, he had evolved this notion to a contention that “world order, a one world order, is necessary to human survival.” One is also reminded of John Adam’s writings to Thomas Jefferson: Rousseau and otherrevolutinary philosophers, said Adams, “preached to the French nation liberty, until they made them the most mechanical slaves; equality till they destroyed all equity; humanity till they became weasels and African panthers; and fraternity till they cut one another’s throats like Roman gladiators.”

How much better were the results of following the truly revolutionary precepts of Adam Smith. He did not appeal to the benevolence of bakers and butchers, you will recall. “We address ourselves,” Smith said, “not to their humanity, but to their self-love, and never talk to them of our necessities, but of their advantages.” The consequence was the feed marketplace and the Industrial Revolution that lifted millions in the West from squalor.

Time and again, however, statists and worshippers of big government reemerge, much like the Leraean Hydra with multiple heads replacing each that is beat back. Jose Ortega y Gasset rightly saw the greatest danger threatening civilization as “State intervention” which is “the absorption of all spontaneous social action by the State,” and which can lead only to the people being “converted into fuel to feed the mere machine which is the State.” As he predicted in 1930 in The Revolt of the Masses: The result of this tendency will be fatal. Spontaneous social action will be broken up over and over again by State intervention; no new seed will be able to fructify. Society will have to live for the State, man for the governmental machine.”

Government is at root simple force and/or the threat of using it. Too much government has sapped us, just as Alexis de  Tocqueville anticipated: “The will of man is not shattered, but softened, bent, and guided; men are seldom forced by it to act, but they are constantly restrained from acting. Such a power does not destroy, but it prevents existence; it does not tyrannize, but it comprises, enervates, extinguishes, and stupefies people, till each nation is reduced to nothing better than a flock of timid and industrious animals, of which the government is the shepherd.”

There are those who are enervated by the fear of stigma, of not being seen as an orthodox interpreter of history, of being accused of seeing incipient totalitarians plotting under the beds. In the name of modernism, however, it is they who surrender skepticism. They will look at our long list of national and international “errors” and deny even the possibility that the fix is in. From the top, Establishment historians will contend that none of this happened because men connived to make this happen. The less such popinjays of the hour know about what they scoff at as the “conspiracy theory” — as if there were one set by dogma — the more they disavow its validity.

If everyone on your side of the street says, for instance, that the Emperor has such a fine set of clothes, and how nice it is that he has recorded it’s details with the People’s Academy of Haphazard History, you may think it odd to note in the face of official history to the contrary that the Emperor is naked as a jaybird. There really is none so blind as the man who will not see. Moreover, as Machiavelli pointed out: One who deceives will always find those who allow themselves to be deceived.”

                                                     ***

A word on style. Most material in this book appeared over a decade, from 1975 to 1984, in   different format in American Opinion magazine. The emphasis has been on making the information glow in a popular and readable fashion rather than litter the landscape with legions of op. cits. And other paraphernalia of merely academic tomes. By incorporating cite works into the body of this history we have sought to minimize the page-turning to minute type. A bibliography of volumes referred to in the text is included at the back.

Finally let me add my gratitude to my parents, John P Hoar and Helen R. Hoar; my friend and Editor, Scott Stanley Jr.; and, my wife, Louisa Miller Hoar.

                                                                                  W.P.H.

Arlington, Massachusetts     

August 1984

 

 

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *